We hear some version of “wait, how do I actually order this?” almost every week, usually from someone who found us on Instagram, fell in love with a photo, and then hit our website not sure where to click. Fair. We run two different ordering paths depending on what you want, and if you land on the wrong one, it can feel more confusing than it needs to be. Here’s exactly how it works.
Quick answer
Have a ready-made design in mind? Order directly through our Signature Store, only 3 business days needed. Have your own vision? Start with our contact form so we can design and price it before you pay anything.
First, figure out which kind of cake you want
Option 1: A Signature Cake. These are our pre-designed, ready-to-order styles, vintage Lambeth piping, themed number cakes, graduation cakes, and more, listed with real prices on our site. You pick the size, flavor, and any small customization (a name, a date, a color swap) directly at checkout. No back-and-forth needed.
Option 2: A fully custom cake. This is for a specific vision, your own inspiration photo, a character, a sculpted element, a particular color story that doesn’t match one of our existing designs. This path starts with a conversation, not a checkout button, because we need to actually design and price your idea.
Here’s the mistake we see most often: someone with a fully custom idea in mind tries to force it through the Signature Store checkout, gets confused when there’s nowhere to upload their inspiration photo, and assumes something’s broken. Nothing’s broken, you’re just on the wrong path for what you want. If in doubt, reach out first and we’ll point you the right direction, or check our FAQ page for other common ordering questions.
If you’re mainly trying to figure out what your cake will cost before you commit to a path, our post on how much a custom cake costs breaks that down in detail.
Ordering a Signature Cake (the fast path)
- Go to raleighcakes.com/store and browse the designs.
- Pick your cake, choose the size (this also tells you the serving count) and flavor combination.
- Add any notes in the order comments, a name, a message, a small tweak. If you’re not sure whether a custom touch is a “leave a note” change or a “needs a real quote” change, err on the side of asking; some of our Signature Cakes accept minor free customizations.
- Check out and pay in full. Signature Cakes require only 3 business days’ lead time, and the store will not let you select a pickup or delivery date sooner than that, so if a date is available at checkout, it’s genuinely available.
- Pick up (or arrange delivery) at the date and time you selected. Full pickup and delivery details, including our Wake Forest studio address, are at raleighcakes.com/pickup-delivery.
Ordering a fully custom cake (the design path)

Cupcakes, parfaits, and dessert table add-ons can be built into a custom order too.
- Fill out our contact form with your event date, headcount, and as much detail as you can, an inspiration photo or two goes a long way. Pinterest and Google Images both work fine for reference; just know we’ll interpret them in our own scratch-made, hand-piped style rather than replicating them exactly, especially if the photo is AI-generated (more on that below).
- We’ll follow up, usually within a day, with questions if we need them and a real price based on your design, not a guess. If your budget is tighter than the design calls for, tell us; we’d genuinely rather adjust the concept (swap a sculpted element for a toy topper, simplify the piping) than quote you something that doesn’t work for you.
- Once you’re happy with the design and price, we send a custom agreement and an invoice for a 50% deposit. That deposit is what actually locks in your date. We work first-to-book, not first-to-ask, so an unpaid inquiry can still lose its slot to someone else who pays first, especially close to busy weekends.
- The remaining balance is due 7 days before your event. We’ll invoice you automatically; no need to track the date yourself.
- We build your cake fresh, right before your event (we don’t believe in cakes sitting around for days), and you pick up or we deliver at the scheduled window.
“We’d rather adjust the concept than quote you something that doesn’t work for you.”
One honest heads-up on inspiration photos: if you send us something AI-generated, know that the lettering and fine detail in those images usually isn’t achievable in real buttercream or fondant (AI tends to invent text and textures that don’t physically pipe), and we can’t promise an exact 1:1 replica. We can usually get remarkably close, and we’ll tell you specifically what we’d need to adjust and why.
A quick note on what we don’t do
We’re not a walk-in storefront, so there’s no browsing a case in person, and we don’t sell standalone custom cupcakes (only as an add-on to a cake order). We also don’t do traditional sheet cakes; if that’s genuinely what you need for a big, budget-conscious gathering, an elevated two-tier design is usually a better in-style alternative at a similar cost, and for the truly no-frills option, your local grocery store bakery will serve you better than we can.
The one thing that makes ordering go smoothly
Whichever path you’re on, the single best thing you can do is give us your real headcount and your real budget upfront. We’re not trying to talk you into more cake than you need, and we’d much rather design toward your number than send you three rounds of quotes that keep missing it. Tell us where you want to land, and we’ll build the best cake we can inside that number. And if your event is coming up fast, our post on ordering a cake last-minute covers what’s realistic on short notice.
Ready to place your order?
Pick whichever path fits what you’re picturing.
Raleigh Cakes is a scratch-made custom cake studio in Wake Forest, NC, serving Raleigh, Durham, Cary, Apex, Chapel Hill, Holly Springs, and the rest of the Triangle. Delivery is available up to 1.5 hours from our studio.


